19 March 2006 - Sunday
Keeping it real
Peter Wood, provost at The King's College, a Christian school in New York City, has closed TKC's school of education.
I wanted my little college to cease feeding the monster. Schools of education mis-prepare would-be teachers in many ways. They deprive those would-be teachers of the opportunity to learn more important, substantive things during their undergraduate years; they require students to take hugely time-consuming courses of dubious intellectual value; and they inculcate would-be teachers in the educrats' pernicious ideology. It's an ideology that insists that virtually all of America's social problems derive from institutionalized prejudices; that most knowledge is "socially constructed;" and that children are best taught by allowing their natural creativity to flourish, rather than by actually trying to teach the habits of self-discipline and mindfulness.Via University Diaries.
Update: Ralph Luker points to Arthur Levine's recent defense of schools of education.
We blame the institution for all of the problems in its field and deem its inability to change willful.| Posted by Wilson at 18:53 Central | TrackBackThat is what is happening today when critics hold education schools responsible for many of the problems of underprepared students who fail at the transition between school and college. But the expectations for education schools are misplaced: They are being asked to carry out activities that they were never intended to perform and that they lack the capacity to achieve.
| Report submitted to the Education Desk
You make a good point. I originally planned to append some comments of my own to the section I quoted, but decided against it because my comments would have been exactly what Wood's are -- generalizations -- and I have much less familiarity with schools of education than he. In any case, I wish Wood had stuck to a cricism of the academic validity of the SOE curricula in his state rather than make his remarks sound so political.
The thoughts of Wilson on 22 March 2006 - 13:38 Central+ + + + +
(You must preview your comment before posting it)

The thing that depresses me about this sort of announcement, is that the debate is constantly hi-jacked by loudmouths spouting polarised views.
As always, real teachers get good results with a healthy mix of insights derived from understanding that many (not virtually all) social problems are caused by institutional prejudice, (OK, I'll give him the argument that many people do think that knowledge is socially constructed) that children can benefit from being allowed to flourish creatively, AND that habits of self discipline and "mindfulness" (might need a US to UK dictionary to explain that word) help a child to suceed to learn.
sigh...
The thoughts of Ed Podesta on 22 March 2006 - 11:58 Central+ + + + +